International vs. US Relative Performance

Relative strength of developed-markets ex-US (EFA) and emerging-markets (EEM) stocks against the US (SPY), indexed since EEM's 2003 inception, split by the direction of the US dollar.
Loading...
Developed/US Ratio
…
Indexed to 100 at EEM's inception
12-Month Relative Return
…
EFA vs. SPY, trailing 252 trading days
Current Dollar Regime
…
Avg. monthly spread return, this regime
Correlation w/ EUR/USD Δ
…
Monthly, Pearson r

Developed / US ratio, since 2003

EFA adjusted close ÷ SPY adjusted close, indexed to 100 at EEM's inception. Rising means developed international is outperforming.

Emerging / US ratio, since 2003

EEM adjusted close ÷ SPY adjusted close, indexed to 100 at EEM's inception. Rising means emerging markets are outperforming.

US vs. developed markets ex-US, year by year

SPY vs. EFA calendar-year total return. Full calendar years only — the first (partial, since EEM inception) and current (still in progress) years are excluded.

Trailing return ladder

Total return (dividends reinvested) by region, as of the last close.
Loading…
1M–1Y are cumulative returns; 3Y/5Y/10Y are annualized. Developed = EFA (MSCI EAFE proxy), Emerging = EEM (MSCI Emerging Markets proxy), US = SPY (S&P 500 proxy).

Rolling 12-month relative return

Developed/US ratio's trailing 252-trading-day return. Positive stretches are international-leadership regimes, negative stretches are US-leadership regimes.

Average monthly spread return by dollar regime

Months classified by the trailing 3-month change in EUR/USD. Bars show the average developed-vs-US monthly return within each regime.

Monthly spread return vs. change in EUR/USD

Each point is one month. X is the month's % change in EUR/USD (a rising value means a weaker dollar), Y is that month's developed-vs-US return.

Methodology

Data. International and US exposure are proxied by three liquid ETFs instead of the underlying indices: EFA (iShares MSCI EAFE ETF) for developed markets ex-US, EEM (iShares MSCI Emerging Markets ETF) for emerging markets, and SPY (SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust) for the US. Yahoo Finance's daily adjusted-close series (dividends and splits applied) gives a total-return comparison for all three in US-dollar terms. The ETFs already include the currency translation a US investor would experience, so no separate FX adjustment is applied. The ratio series is indexed to 100 at EEM's April 2003 inception, which sets how far back the page can go (EFA trades back to 2001 and SPY to 1993).

Dollar regimes. Each calendar month is classified by the trailing 3-month % change in EUR/USD (Yahoo Finance EURUSD=X, month-end close). A rise of more than 2% is "Dollar Weakening," a fall of more than 2% is "Dollar Strengthening," and anything in between is "Flat." EUR/USD is one currency pair, not a trade-weighted dollar index, so treat the regime split as a rough proxy for dollar direction. The idea being tested is that a weaker dollar should boost unhedged international returns (the translation effect). The regime averages below are a small, noisy sample (a couple dozen months per regime), so read them as suggestive, not conclusive.

Correlation. The scatter shows Pearson (OLS) and Spearman rank correlation, as on Factor Analysis and Small Cap vs. Large Cap Spread, so one or two extreme months can't carry the result. A low r² is expected. One currency pair rarely explains much of a monthly equity-return series, and the regression is there to show how weak or strong that single relationship is.

Refreshes once daily after the US market close, since index levels move every trading day. The EUR/USD monthly series is pulled in full each run.

Source: Yahoo Finance daily adjusted close (EFA, EEM, SPY) and EURUSD=X month-end close.